Księgi Jakubowe

Księgi Jakubowe

  • Downloads:9700
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2022-07-09 09:52:10
  • Update Date:2025-09-07
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Olga Tokarczuk
  • ISBN:8308076068
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

Rok 1752。 Do Rohatyna na Podolu przybywają kasztelanowa Katarzyna Kossakowska i towarzysząca jej poetka Elżbieta Drużbacka。 Jednym z gości na powitalnej kolacji jest miejscowy proboszcz Benedykt Chmielowski, autor pierwszej polskiej encyklopedii。 Ksiądz i poetka, osoby rozmiłowane w księgach, szybko znajdują wspólny język – rozpoczynają rozmowę, którą później kontynuować będą w listach。

Nieco później, także na Podolu, pojawia się młody, przystojny i charyzmatyczny Żyd - Jakub Lejbowicz Frank。 Tajemniczy przybysz z odległej Smyrny zaczyna głosić idee, które szybko dzielą społeczność żydowską。 Dla jednych heretyk, dla innych zbawca już niebawem ma wokół siebie krąg oddanych sobie uczniów, zaś wywołany przezeń ferment może odmienić bieg historii。

Niemal tysiąc stron, kilkadziesiąt wątków i postaci — Księgi Jakubowe imponują literackim rozmachem, wielością poziomów i możliwych interpretacji。 Olga Tokarczuk pełnymi garściami czerpie z tradycji powieści historycznej, poszerzając jednocześnie jej granice gatunkowe。 Z ogromną dbałością o szczegóły przedstawia realia epoki, architekturę, ubiory, zapachy。 Odwiedzamy szlacheckie dwory, katolickie plebanie i żydowskie domostwa, rozmodlone i zanurzone w lekturze tajemniczych pism。 Na oczach czytelników pisarka tka obraz dawnej Polski, w której egzystowały obok siebie chrześcijaństwo, judaizm, a także islam。

Księgi Jakubowe to nie tylko powieść o przeszłości。 Można ją czytać również jako refleksyjne, momentami mistyczne dzieło o samej historii, jej zakrętach i trybach, które decydują o losach całych narodów。 To właśnie w połowie XVIII wieku, u progu Oświecenia i przed rozbiorami, wybitna pisarka poszukuje odpowiedzi na pytania o dzisiejszy kształt naszej części Europy。

Download

Reviews

Ben Platt

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers。 To view it, click here。 Truly remarkable。 The amount of texture Tokarczuk imparts to the history of the Frankists, the environment from which they emerged out of (including the deep-rooted antisemitism embedded in every society the novel touches and stoked by the actions of the Frankists themselves, who end up betraying the Jewish communities of Poland), the theology guiding each character, the contradictory and complicated characters themselves… it’s pretty incredible。 The tapestry that Tokarczuk is able to weave from Truly remarkable。 The amount of texture Tokarczuk imparts to the history of the Frankists, the environment from which they emerged out of (including the deep-rooted antisemitism embedded in every society the novel touches and stoked by the actions of the Frankists themselves, who end up betraying the Jewish communities of Poland), the theology guiding each character, the contradictory and complicated characters themselves… it’s pretty incredible。 The tapestry that Tokarczuk is able to weave from the historical evidence and through her own imagination places history and literature in a symbiotic relationship with each other, the former being, as Tokarczuk writes in the Notes on Sources, “the unceasing attempt to understand what it is that has happened alongside all that might have happened as well or instead” (5) while the latter, as one of her characters, Julian Brinken/Aleksander Bronikowski puts it, can perhaps be seen as a “ particular type of knowledge… the perfection of imprecise forms” (14)。 I regret not taking more notes as I read, but maybe it’s appropriate that I leave that for a second read; after all, “so many things remain quietly connected” (5) to each other across history (whatever history means) and literature (whatever literature is), and maybe those connections will be more apparent next time。I’m honestly surprised to have closed the book with a desire to read it again – not immediately, I need a break, but perhaps next time I begin to feel the need for a new order of things that upends the old。 I suppose I feel that every day given the world we live in, but there is a specific texture to Books of Jacob and its exploration of/it’s character’s desire for order in a disordered world that is different from my experience: Books of Jacob is, partially, a theodicy, but rather than arising out of the Christian tradition (like the notable theodicy Paradise Lost), this novel arises out of the questions the Jewish communities living in Poland have regarding their constant suffering at the hands of the world around them。 In response to this question, which Tokarczuk connects to larger philosophical questions without (to my eyes) ever losing the Jewish foundation of the novel, various characters propose a wide range of answers, ways of creating a divine order from the chaos of the world, whether that be the heretical unification of Judaism, Islam, and Christianity or the establishment of the Enlightenment to brush away the mysticism of the past, which places the old order of things under the lens of terror and insurrection, labeling unorthodox religious beliefs as dangerous and that, according to King Frederick Wilhelm, “we ought now, after the frightening and terrible experiences of the Revolution in France and their connections with Jacobinism, to change our perspective and treat mystical rituals as a cover for political and revolutionary intentions” (56)。 The order of things has changed and will change, because, as Tokarczuk writes, “every order, every system, is simply a matter of what you’ve gotten used to” (5), with all the political and social implications such orders imply。All in all, Tokarczuk is brilliant and this book is an amazing achievement, a grandiose novel on an enormous scale sustained by Tokarczuk’s attention to small details and vibrant prose (translated beautifully by Jennifer Croft)。 It inspired me to write too much for a Goodreads review and I feel as though there is so much left to be said。 。。。more

Rebecca

Things I really liked -Magical realism, a deeply evocative portrait of 18th century Poland on the brink of chaos, with clear effort put into the historical research and research of Jewish customs, presenting Polish-Jewish relations as being complex, the illustrations/graphics throughoutThings I did not -The book is definitely longer than it needed to be; while I really enjoyed it at the start, I was struggling at the end。 Also towards the end there is a significant error with the Hebrew; I am as Things I really liked -Magical realism, a deeply evocative portrait of 18th century Poland on the brink of chaos, with clear effort put into the historical research and research of Jewish customs, presenting Polish-Jewish relations as being complex, the illustrations/graphics throughoutThings I did not -The book is definitely longer than it needed to be; while I really enjoyed it at the start, I was struggling at the end。 Also towards the end there is a significant error with the Hebrew; I am assuming this is a translator or printer error as opposed to author error as the author has otherwise done very well at portraying Jewish customs。Over all, I think I liked it, but if it was 200-300 pages shorter, I probably would have loved it。 。。。more

Emma Jane

insane

Kathleen Mahnke

Such a hard book for me to rate。 So powerful。 So well-written。 So thorough。 Sooooo long。 I think that maybe if I had known more about the history of Poland and its neighbors during the time period covered in this book, I could have better appreciated the careful attention to detail that Tokarczuk devotes to each and every moment she describes。 I did learn a lot about messianic movements。 The story of Jacob Frank, though different in many ways, reminded me much of the story of Jesus Christ。 And t Such a hard book for me to rate。 So powerful。 So well-written。 So thorough。 Sooooo long。 I think that maybe if I had known more about the history of Poland and its neighbors during the time period covered in this book, I could have better appreciated the careful attention to detail that Tokarczuk devotes to each and every moment she describes。 I did learn a lot about messianic movements。 The story of Jacob Frank, though different in many ways, reminded me much of the story of Jesus Christ。 And the modern evangelical movement, too, to a certain extent。 。。。more

Torne

3,5 stars。 This is not my cup of tea。 I intellectually can appreciate the way the book is written but the story, the world will not stay with me。 I'm a simple man so I like simple stories like "Ægypt Cycle" by John Crowley。 3,5 stars。 This is not my cup of tea。 I intellectually can appreciate the way the book is written but the story, the world will not stay with me。 I'm a simple man so I like simple stories like "Ægypt Cycle" by John Crowley。 。。。more

Adam Dalva

Extraordinary how strong an achievement BOOKS OF JACOB ended up being - the more I think about the scope and ambition of the project, the better it seems to me。 It’s the story of a cult - a real one, Jacob Frank - and the first 250 pages or so are about the collection of the figures of the cult。 The boldness of the text (it counts backward instead of forward, is narrated by a woman who can’t die, has interpolated photos and pictures and many forms of prose), the transportive quality of the resea Extraordinary how strong an achievement BOOKS OF JACOB ended up being - the more I think about the scope and ambition of the project, the better it seems to me。 It’s the story of a cult - a real one, Jacob Frank - and the first 250 pages or so are about the collection of the figures of the cult。 The boldness of the text (it counts backward instead of forward, is narrated by a woman who can’t die, has interpolated photos and pictures and many forms of prose), the transportive quality of the research, and the plot, which really gets its hooks in as it goes, is all very notable。 And what a translation by Croft! Very grateful to have read it 。。。more

Michael Rieman

It can prove difficult for a reader to follow the changing settings of this "historical novel" which is set in eighteenth century Eastern Europe, in lands which were once Poland-Lithuania, and other areas of Europe that today are parts of Poland, Romania, and even Germany。 Borders seemed to be relatively porous in this novel, and involve whole communities moving from one area to another (even Ottoman Turkey is involved)。 Changes of location aren't the only ones which interest the author。 The cha It can prove difficult for a reader to follow the changing settings of this "historical novel" which is set in eighteenth century Eastern Europe, in lands which were once Poland-Lithuania, and other areas of Europe that today are parts of Poland, Romania, and even Germany。 Borders seemed to be relatively porous in this novel, and involve whole communities moving from one area to another (even Ottoman Turkey is involved)。 Changes of location aren't the only ones which interest the author。 The characters, mostly from the Jewish community, make changes not only in location, but in their religion and even their names as they follow Jacob Frank, a man who presents himself in a Messianic tradition, disrupts traditional life and gathers increasing numbers of adherents。Was Frank a "false Messiah"? The author always holds out that possibility and we have good reason to think so。 Frank's confidence in his teachings certainly drew others to reject the traditional practices and rules set down in the Talmud。 His adherents gave up much for him and eventually supported him in a relatively affluent style。 He enjoyed being considered a "Lord" and living with the finery that nobility allows。 He could be demanding, self-serving, and angry。 Tokarczuk does not present his private thoughts, though。 I think that may have been a deliberate choice。 Despite the extraordinary length of this novel, in which the reader is well aware of Frank's behavior and emotional states, the reader does not have access to his private thoughts。 We do not know whether his teachings and beliefs have a true spiritual basis, but it is possible that he in fact believed they did。The narrative chronicles the development, growth, and ultimate dispersal of a Jewish community that was drawn to Frank and maintained a material and spiritual allegiance to him。 His rejection of traditional laws and rituals of the Talmud, and the replacement of these practices with radical acts including sexual rituals, provoked the anger of Traditionalists who resorted to both violence and lawsuits against the sect。Yet, that community was often aided by sympathetic members of the Christian community who either did not wish to get involved with those internal disagreements, had business connections with some of the adherents, or, when Frank was baptized and urged others to do so, wanted to assist the conversions of these Jews to the Catholic faith。 That may seem for readers another of the bewildering changes in the novel。 The characters change their names and appearances as they change their faith。 Tokarczuk helps us along very often by reminding us of who they were before that change, but the reader must be careful to keep all that in mind in a book with so many characters。 I found it easier to just "go with the flow" and let the novel work its own strategy。 Ultimately, that worked for me。 While there is a fluidity involved in the fortunes and identities of some characters, there is also a core that is consistent。 Late in the novel, when a character is questioned about why the members of the community seem to marry among themselves and stick to each other in many affairs, he responds that the same thing is true for other ethnic groups within the larger fabric of the society。 Frank himself, though adopting a Catholic faith, views the representation of the Virgin Mary as concealing the "Shekinah," a female representation of the soul found in the Hebrew Kabbalah。 Nachman, the character most attuned to the spiritual aspects of what he sees in Jacob, also maintains his studies in the numerology that he finds in the Hebrew language。 The borders between what is spiritual and what is material appear throughout the work, and can lead to profound questions which Tokarczuk may suggest but not answer。 Consider Nachman's comments in the "Scraps" he has written : For when the spirit enters a person, it happens as if by violence, as if the air were to penetrate the hardest stone。 Neither the body nor the mind that the spirit has entered are fully aware of what has occurred。 Thus,there must be someone who pronounces it, who names it。 And this is what i did with our holy Mordechai in Smyrna--we were witnesses to the descent of the spirit into Jacob; we put it into wordsDid Nachman himself possess the spiritual light he sees in Jacob? Is there such a light at all? There are so many characters and threads in the novel that each reader must decide which to follow or to accept。 For me, an interesting character was Moliwda, who I viewed in comparison to Jacob。 He too led a life of changes, both in place and name ( he was actually from an aristocratic family)。 He was of great help as a bridge between the Catholic hierarchy and the Jewish converts, and he was fascinated by Jacob。However, he lacked the certainty which seemed to insulate Jacob。 Moliwda was one of the most thoughtful characters in the novel, but he lived with the doubts and uncertainties which are characteristic of the age we live in today。There are so many aspects of the novel which call for further reflection。 I'm sure that as more people complete the novel, there will be much more written about it。 Most historical novels deal with events or persons we already know something about。 Tokarczuk has brought to life a community with which we were probably unfamiliar and has used that to pose questions about life, death, faith, and the borders we may need to cross to better understand our lives。 。。。more

Holly Donnelly

Kind of a slog but some fascinating parts。 I skimmed the last two books。

Hpnyknits

This book was too long。 3。5 A good story and an attempt to explain cults and why are people drawn to false messiahs。 One can’t help but ask - even today with so much access to information, ignorant people are drawn to these manipulative “leaders” grifters really, and their handlers。 The premise was good and the historical background was good, it’s just that it was too long。

Marie Cohen

Gave up after 20 percent。

Bartłomiej Falkowski

Oczywiście, że głównym powodem sięgnięcia przeze mnie po literaturę pani Tokarczuk była Nagroda Nobla。 Wybrałem akurat "Księgi Jakubowe", bo mocno przemówił do mnie zapowiadany klimat książki - osiemnastowieczna Rzeczpospolita, multikulturowość ówczesnego kraju (z wątkami żydowskimi jako podstawa historii), sekta religijna Jakuba Franka。 Wszystko to (wraz z przyznaniem Nobla) brzmiało jak recepta na niesamowitą powieść。 Tak się niestety nie stało - książka mnie "nie porwała"。 Dlaczego?- Zacznę o Oczywiście, że głównym powodem sięgnięcia przeze mnie po literaturę pani Tokarczuk była Nagroda Nobla。 Wybrałem akurat "Księgi Jakubowe", bo mocno przemówił do mnie zapowiadany klimat książki - osiemnastowieczna Rzeczpospolita, multikulturowość ówczesnego kraju (z wątkami żydowskimi jako podstawa historii), sekta religijna Jakuba Franka。 Wszystko to (wraz z przyznaniem Nobla) brzmiało jak recepta na niesamowitą powieść。 Tak się niestety nie stało - książka mnie "nie porwała"。 Dlaczego?- Zacznę od być może niezbyt głębokiego, ale dość ważnego dla mnie wniosku - powieść jest ZA DŁUGA。 O ile w początkowych etapach byłem w stanie znaleźć ciekawe wątki, to mniej więcej od połowy, całość zaczęła się już rozjeżdżać。 Doceniam próby oddania klimatu różnych miejsc, w których przebywał Jakub - Lwów, Warszawa, Częstochowa, Wiedeń。 Jednocześnie, miałem wrażenie, że powieść nigdzie nie dąży - czekamy po prostu na śmierć Franka。- Obietnica przedstawienia klimatu ówczesnej Polski została spełniona tylko połowicznie。 Niektóre fragmenty i postacie faktycznie zapadają w pamięć。 Opisy podróży, przekraczania granic, codziennych problemów (takich jak epidemie, stan dróg, wszechobecna śmierć) są niekiedy bardzo plastyczne。 Całość psuje trochę mocna koncentracja na głównym wątku - sekcie Jakuba Franka。 Ciekawe (dla mnie!) wątki urywają się nagle i są zapomniane。- Nie do końca potrafię odnaleźć przesłanie。 Na pewno mamy tu "podskórną" krytykę małostkowości Polaków - nawet te "dobre" jednostki, która pomagają "przechrztom", robią to w dość cyniczny i przedmiotowy sposób。 Zepsucie elit。 Pokazanie hipokryzji ówczesnych władz kościoła katolickiego - ignorancja, przepych, elitaryzm。 Nie neguję tych obserwacji w żaden sposób。 Mam jednak wrażenie, że były one zbyt natarczywe i jawne。 Patrząc z innej perspektywy, czy głównym przesłaniem jest wolność jednostki? Każdy ma prawo do wyboru własnego "Mesjasza" i podążania ścieżką, którą wybierze。 Ba, każdy ma prawo być "Mesjaszem"。 Religie i tradycje są tylko składnikami, tradycją, którymi możemy dowolnie szuflować。 W każdym razie, niestety nie miałem momentu olśnienia i pełnego zrozumienia w trakcie lektury :(Podsumowując, być może "Księgi Jakubowe" są próbą stworzenia nowej polskiej epopei。 Mamy tu niesamowicie rozległy opis osiemnastowiecznej "polskości", w który wkomponowana jest nowoczesna, dwudziestopierwszowieczna myśl。 W mojej opinii, zabrakło wielu elementów, aby tak mogło się stać。 。。。more

Hanna Gil

Olga Tokarczuk's "The Books of Jacob" is not just a novel; for a reader, it's a commitment。 With almost 1000 pages, the book requires that one has to be willing to enter a different world and spend many hours there。 I was unsure if I wanted to do it, but why not? It's summer, days are longer, and I like the author's style; I read some of her previous books。 My plan was to read one chapter a day – the novel consists of thirty-one of them, combined into five books。 In the end, it turned out that I Olga Tokarczuk's "The Books of Jacob" is not just a novel; for a reader, it's a commitment。 With almost 1000 pages, the book requires that one has to be willing to enter a different world and spend many hours there。 I was unsure if I wanted to do it, but why not? It's summer, days are longer, and I like the author's style; I read some of her previous books。 My plan was to read one chapter a day – the novel consists of thirty-one of them, combined into five books。 In the end, it turned out that I finished it much quicker than anticipated。"The Books of Jacob" is indeed Tokarczuk's opus magnum。 It's based on the life of Jacob Frank, a mysterious Jew who in 18th century Poland proclaimed himself the messiah, denouncing the Talmud and traditional Jewish teachings and customs。 He declared that to find the truth, one has to step into the lowest levels of existence – in practice, it meant leaving the old ways of life - and follow him as a spiritual leader。 Charismatic and vain, he eventually controlled his followers completely, encouraging and even requiring engaging in sexual acts outside of marriage。 He was thought to have supernatural powers and healing abilities; his virility was legendary。The novel can be compared in style to gospels: told by many narrators who follow Jacob, listen to his teachings, and travel with him。 At some point, the sect's beliefs come close to the Catholic faith, which the Polish bishops embrace; they see the baptism of Jews as a massive success in the eyes of the Vatican。 For Jacob's baptized followers, it meant they would be allowed to own land and enjoy many freedoms not available to Jews。 However, what goes up must come down - soon, the interrogations follow, and Jacob is imprisoned for thirteen years, ironically in the most sacred Polish monastery。 Released after the partition of Poland, he spends his last years of life in the Moravian town of Brno, living with his daughter Eve in luxury, surrounded by the entourage of faithful followers, and then moving to Offenbach in Germany。It's interesting that although the novel revolves around Jacob, we don't exactly know what he thinks - we see him through different narrators' eyes。 It's a rich tapestry of opinions, feelings, and characters – some are very likable, others not so much。 Reading this novel was a pleasure, a slow walk in the forest full of scents, sounds, and dances, observing the landscape created so skillfully by the author and, in a way, understanding those 18th century people, their joys and tragedies, fear of death and longing for eternal life。 This is a beautiful, meaningful, and poetic book。 And additionally, it can - literally and metaphorically - stand on its own。 。。。more

Iosef

Olga tokarczuk you are the mother I never had!

Kama

Another DNF。 I made it halfway through this monster before realizing I was dreading continuing with it。 I love me some Olga but this one is a slog-and-a-half。

Nate

A novel that deserves the phrase "tour de force" as well as being a psychedelic tapestry of dozens of people over decades in multiple countries, and in my opinion, a requiem for the spiritual lens which we once walked through life with, before the Age of Reason, whose thinkers start showing up toward the end of the novel, which of course coincides with the slow disbanding of the religious sect that Jacob led。 Tokarczuk does an incredible job of breathing life into these characters, making both m A novel that deserves the phrase "tour de force" as well as being a psychedelic tapestry of dozens of people over decades in multiple countries, and in my opinion, a requiem for the spiritual lens which we once walked through life with, before the Age of Reason, whose thinkers start showing up toward the end of the novel, which of course coincides with the slow disbanding of the religious sect that Jacob led。 Tokarczuk does an incredible job of breathing life into these characters, making both major and minor ones seem real。 Based on the themes in this book, as well as Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead, I wouldn't be surprised if the author considered writing to be an act of magic。 If so, I think she largely succeeds, as the vividness of the time seems to burst with life。 Many, if not most, of the characters are based on real people, as is the titular Jacob, a historical figure I never knew about, who claimed to be the next Messiah, and amassed a significant following。 The book is largely told through the viewpoint of this following, though stories of less involved side characters also take rein of the narration at times, providing the more enjoyable detours of the novel。 (Particularly an invented correspondence between two writers alive during that period; though there is also a doctor who's sections I enjoyed very much)。 The scholarship involved in writing this novel is almost as impressive as the book itself, as are the countless artifacts of art that show up throughout, plates Tokarczuk found during her research。 A wonderful read, especially the last "book", which is essentially an epilogue (I'm a sucker for good endings)。 I liked the focus Drive Your Plow a bit more than Books of Jacob, which is almost encyclopedic in scope (in fact, one of the characters is based on the writer of the first encyclopedia); and the meandering style of the narrative at times tried my patience; but I don't think the book would be effect without the wandering prose; and would recommend this。 I've heard comparisons to old Russian novels, and though the writing style is quite different, it does have a similar feeling to the few I've read。 。。。more

Megan Rosol

Historical, mystical, massive。 It's beautifully-written and narrated, and original in its subject matter but it was just too long and turned into a countdown for me。 I feel like re-reading her Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead。 Historical, mystical, massive。 It's beautifully-written and narrated, and original in its subject matter but it was just too long and turned into a countdown for me。 I feel like re-reading her Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead。 。。。more

Audrey

A whole lot of book

Brian Cohen

I did it! Well, I listened to 75% of it。 Great epic novel showing how movements that seem so monumental simply disappear into time。 I’d love to watch a documentary about the writing of it, what’s taken from existing sources, what’s invented, etc。 It was hard to keep track of all the characters, at least while listening。 Not helped by the fact that they all change their names halfway through。 Definitely a book I can see myself revisiting。

Symulakrum

Przebrnęłam, doceniam, ale to za dużo na mój mózg。 Od połowy nie miałam już z czytania przyjemności, tylko walczyłam ze sobą, żeby to skończyć。

Lynne

Interesting。。。。the book is written forward, but pages are numbered backwards。。。makes it a wee bit more difficult to keep track of "pages read"。。。one has to subtract the page they are currently on from the total number of pages in the book。。。 Interesting。。。。the book is written forward, but pages are numbered backwards。。。makes it a wee bit more difficult to keep track of "pages read"。。。one has to subtract the page they are currently on from the total number of pages in the book。。。 。。。more

Ellen

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers。 To view it, click here。 "The Messiah will complete his painful journey, destroying empty worlds from within, reducing dead laws to rubble。 We must, thus, annihilate the old order so that the new order may prevail。"I had no idea that there was a Jewish sect, in 1750's which redefined their beliefs to insist that Moses misled his people in Sinai, that the true God had be found, and that the Jews needed to abandon their "dead" laws and practices in search of the true Trinity。 This very large group was led by a charismatic "The Messiah will complete his painful journey, destroying empty worlds from within, reducing dead laws to rubble。 We must, thus, annihilate the old order so that the new order may prevail。"I had no idea that there was a Jewish sect, in 1750's which redefined their beliefs to insist that Moses misled his people in Sinai, that the true God had be found, and that the Jews needed to abandon their "dead" laws and practices in search of the true Trinity。 This very large group was led by a charismatic leader, Jacob Frank, a man of many names, and many visions。 Attacked by both traditional Jews for basterdizing the faith as well as suspicious Catholics, Jacob led his followers to convert to Catholicism as part of his mystical definition of the Trinity。 Much more covered in this long book。。 。。。more

Brenda Wright

Whew, what a monster of a read but I learned a lot about the lives of Eastern Europeans of the 1700s。 It was mesmerizing to read for its vast topic。 And I was thrilled to learn it was based on an historical figure。 I suggest listening to it。

Joyce Peterson

I give up on this one。 Loved her other books in translation but just can’t slog through it。

Mark

This historical novel traces the rise and fall of charismatic messianic figure Jacob Frank in 18th century Europe。 His movement blended Judaism, Islam and Christianity to suit his purposes and his followers stuck with him through many trials and odd ritualistic turns。 Its great length (nearly 1,000 pages) and sometimes exhaustive detail can test the reader, but it is a brilliantly conceived and constructed novel by a Nobel prize-winning author of immense talent。

Dawn

Read mostly while traveling for work in Palo Alto。 There were large sections of this book that felt too unwieldy — complicated genealogies, nationalities, histories and geographies。 Having almost no knowledge of the Jewish faith or Polish history; I’m a poor reader for a novel like this。 I felt it was more of a collection than a novel。 Like a huge bundle of magazines from a hundred year period that the reader is tasked with putting together (or not putting together, in my case)。 But as strange a Read mostly while traveling for work in Palo Alto。 There were large sections of this book that felt too unwieldy — complicated genealogies, nationalities, histories and geographies。 Having almost no knowledge of the Jewish faith or Polish history; I’m a poor reader for a novel like this。 I felt it was more of a collection than a novel。 Like a huge bundle of magazines from a hundred year period that the reader is tasked with putting together (or not putting together, in my case)。 But as strange as most of the material was to me, there was a coziness in these 900 pages that I can’t deny。 A pervasive, deep coziness。 The writing zips between people and places in little 10 page bursts, landing always on intensely physical/corporeal details while not dwelling much on psychological or even literary themes。 A weird book。 And a nice if somewhat difficult change of pace for me。 。。。more

Michael Milgrom

There’s a lot to like here but also a lot to not like。 I find myself agreeing with both the positive and negative reviews though I can’t get into the really glowing ones。 I listened to most of this book and the two narrators are excellent but I couldn’t finish it in 21 days so I got the ebook。 This was a good decision because I got to see the illustrations。 What’s to like: A deep exploration, at a granular level, of an obscure part of history: The Polish kingdom/republic in it’s dying years from There’s a lot to like here but also a lot to not like。 I find myself agreeing with both the positive and negative reviews though I can’t get into the really glowing ones。 I listened to most of this book and the two narrators are excellent but I couldn’t finish it in 21 days so I got the ebook。 This was a good decision because I got to see the illustrations。 What’s to like: A deep exploration, at a granular level, of an obscure part of history: The Polish kingdom/republic in it’s dying years from 1750 or so, onwards, and the bizarre episode of the Frankists, a heretical sect of Jews that went all the way to converting to Christianity in pursuit of their messianic vision。 Many of the characters, especially the non-Jewish ones, were finely drawn and memorable。 The evocation of the era was convincing。The negatives: So many characters I lost track of some, especially the ones who changed their names halfway through。 I never did figure out the point of Yente, the neither dead nor alive character。 I didn’t care about the details of Jacob’s theology which was incoherent and repetitive without being interesting。 The same goes for the constant philosophizing of Nahman, the Frankists’ scribe。 Finally, while the illustrations were interesting I cannot understand why there were no captions。 Some appeared to be actual representations of something in the book while others appeared to be just examples of something like a thing described in the book。 I don’t know why an author would do this when it would be easy to do。 。。。more

Jeremy

Or, its telling secondary title: “A Fantastic Journey Across Seven Borders, Five Languages, and Three Major Religions, not Counting the Minor Sects”。 And what an epic, centuries-spanning journey it was。 Tokarczuk’s prose never fails to fascinate with her tapestry of hundreds of characters and their meditations and movements in a setting (Ukraine-Poland-Turkey, late 18th century) I knew little about。 The amount of characters, pages, and overall information can be grueling, but I was almost always Or, its telling secondary title: “A Fantastic Journey Across Seven Borders, Five Languages, and Three Major Religions, not Counting the Minor Sects”。 And what an epic, centuries-spanning journey it was。 Tokarczuk’s prose never fails to fascinate with her tapestry of hundreds of characters and their meditations and movements in a setting (Ukraine-Poland-Turkey, late 18th century) I knew little about。 The amount of characters, pages, and overall information can be grueling, but I was almost always charmed by the characters’ daily trajectories, passions, and wanderings。 The connections she makes by the end of the book with this mountain of impressive research are like a minor miracle and show the lasting power of literature。 It’s a historical literary novel that reminded me of Mann’s Joseph and his Brothers, while thankfully being antithetical to it in almost every way。 。。。more

Michael Barron

Thought the subject matter sounded cool and I like long books but this was an absolute chore。 Finished it only out of pride。 Weird ritual fetish stuff every thirty pages。 I get it’s historical fiction so maybe it’s just trying to be true to events as they happened but I was like seriously just chill out man。 Second star given for illustrations that both look cool and reduce the amount of words on any given page。 Should’ve known better when I opened up the dust jacket and saw that the author is a Thought the subject matter sounded cool and I like long books but this was an absolute chore。 Finished it only out of pride。 Weird ritual fetish stuff every thirty pages。 I get it’s historical fiction so maybe it’s just trying to be true to events as they happened but I was like seriously just chill out man。 Second star given for illustrations that both look cool and reduce the amount of words on any given page。 Should’ve known better when I opened up the dust jacket and saw that the author is a white chick with dreads 。。。more

Debbie

This book was kind of a Bible- I think I would need to read it over and over and discuss with others to get the impact。 It centers around the false messiah but the author creates a tense hypothetical world , very rich but with so many details it’s hard to get it all in the one time around。

Paul

One of the best novels I have read in a while。 Very interesting subject with some magical excursions and fascinating characters。 It is an investment in time but worth the ride。